Disappointment turns to disbelief
Following our update after the Full Council meeting on 15 July, we have some further detail to share — and it has taken us from disappointment to disbelief.
Please read this first. Havant Borough Council has not yet published the official minutes or voting record. Everything below is transcribed from the audio recording of the meeting. We believe it to be accurate, but it is not the official record, and we will correct anything the official record contradicts. Specific caveats are listed beneath the table.
The vote
The Long Copse Lane amendment, raised by Councillor Charles Robert, was lost on a tied vote — 15 for, 15 against, 3 abstentions. Councillor Paul Tansom, as Mayor, then used his casting vote against the amendment, in line with the vote he had already cast, and the amendment fell.
Three councillors abstained: Cllr Reuben Mychaleckyj (Green, Emsworth), Cllr Ryan Brent (Conservative, Waterloo) and Cllr Paul Gray (Independent, Hayling West).
Any one of those abstentions, cast in favour, would have carried the amendment outright and referred the Plan back to Cabinet for review.
Why we have written to our own ward councillor
Our concern rests with Councillor Mychaleckyj in particular, because he is the Green Party councillor for Emsworth — the very ward Long Copse Lane sits within — and because of the commitments he made to residents at the hustings and in his campaign leaflets.
His two fellow Emsworth councillors, Cllr Grainne Rason and Cllr Charles Robert, both voted for the amendment. He did not join them.
We have written to him to ask for his commitment to support Long Copse Lane going forward.
Read our letter to Cllr Mychaleckyj (PDF)
We would now ask you to do the same. If you share our concern, please consider writing to him yourself — politely and constructively.
To be clear: our aim is not to alienate Councillor Mychaleckyj, but to influence him. There is likely to be a further full Council vote on this Plan once it has been revised following the Regulation 19 consultation, and we want him to vote differently when that moment comes.
Email Cllr Mychaleckyj — opens an email to him, copied to the other Emsworth councillors.
The recorded vote
| Party | Councillor | Ward | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reform UK | Cllr Jason Beal | Bedhampton | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Sharon Collings | Leigh Park Central & West Leigh | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Caren Diamond | Purbrook | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Jason Gillen | Hart Plain | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Sarah Milne | Stakes | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Terry Norton | Stakes | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Kev Parsons | Cowplain | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Michael Rennie | Hayling East | For |
| Reform UK | Cllr Gwen Robinson | Waterloo | For |
| Labour | Cllr Daniel Berwick | Havant St. Faith's | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Richard Brown | Leigh Park Hermitage | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Munazza Faiz | Leigh Park Central & West Leigh | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Gillian Harris | Havant St. Faith's | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Jason Horton | Leigh Park Central & West Leigh | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Philip Munday | Havant St. Faith's | Against |
| Labour | Cllr Amy Redsull | Leigh Park Hermitage | Against |
| Green Party | Cllr Mark Coates | Hayling East | Against |
| Green Party | Cllr Jonathan Hulls | Hayling West | Against |
| Green Party | Cllr Reuben Mychaleckyj | Emsworth | Abstain |
| Green Party | Cllr Grainne Rason | Emsworth | For |
| Green Party | Cllr Charles Robert | Emsworth | For |
| Green Party | Cllr Netty Shepherd | Hayling East | Against |
| Liberal Democrats | Cllr Wilf Forrow | Hayling West | Against |
| Liberal Democrats | Cllr Philippa Gray | Bedhampton | For |
| Liberal Democrats | Cllr Antonia Harrison | Purbrook | Against |
| Liberal Democrats | Cllr Michael Lind | Bedhampton | Against |
| Liberal Democrats | Cllr Paul Tansom (Mayor) | Purbrook | Against |
| Conservatives | Cllr Ryan Brent | Waterloo | Abstain |
| Conservatives | Cllr David Keast | Cowplain | For |
| Conservatives | Cllr Peter Wade | Waterloo | For |
| Independent | Cllr Elaine Shimbart | Hart Plain | For |
| Independent for Hayling West | Cllr Paul Gray | Hayling West | Abstain |
Total: 15 for, 15 against, 3 abstentions — a tie, broken by the Mayor's casting vote against the amendment.
The table above lists 32 councillors and shows 14 recorded against, because Cllr Berwick's vote was inaudible in the recording (see below). With his vote counted as against, the substantive result is the 15–15 tie announced in the chamber. Cllr Tansom's casting vote, as Mayor, was made in addition to the vote he had already cast.
Caveats on this table
- Cllr Berwick's vote was inaudible in the recording. It is shown as Against because he spoke against the amendment during the debate. This is an inference, not a record.
- Three councillors were not called in the recording: Cllr Neil Bowdell (Conservative, Cowplain), Cllr Ann Briggs (Conservative, Hart Plain) and Cllr Vicky Rhodes (Reform UK, Leigh Park Hermitage).
- Names have been reconciled against the Council's published councillor lists. The roll-call audio rendered some surnames differently.
If you believe anything here is wrong, please tell us and we will check it against the recording and correct it.
The Regulation 19 consultation — the date that matters
The Regulation 19 consultation is the next and most important opportunity for residents to be heard.
It runs from 20 July to 9 September 2026. All representations must be received by 5.00pm on Wednesday 9 September 2026.
Representations at this stage concern the legal compliance and soundness of the Local Plan, rather than general objections. The form and the guidance note explaining what that means are on the Council's website:
If you make one representation this year, make it this one.